How to Kill a Samurai: Part 1. How NOT to kill a Samurai!

Modern sporting Kendo came into mainstream popularity in Japan and later the west after the defeat of the Japanese empire by the Americans at the end of the second world war. As such it definitely falls into the category of gendai budo, that is to say budo propagated after the second world war, and generally with strong focus on the sporting and competitive aspects of the martial arts (though this theme is not universal even among gendai budo arts). That is not to say that kendo does not have aspects of the koryu left in it. Many of its kata are derived or even directly transplanted from old ryuha, and in this way kendo maintains a strong link with the arts that preceded it. There is a misconception, however, more amongst those unfamiliar with kendo practice than those deeply immersed in it, that kendo is accurately representative of samurai combat, and more specifically, armoured combat.

There are four main ways to score in kendo, four different areas where strikes are considered valid.

1. Men, or the head, is a vertical strike to the top of the skull.

Men2

Image Courtesy of empty mind films

As we can see when we apply this strike against samurai armour, however, it is rendered ineffective by the kabuto. Many reading this article may, at this point be thinking this obvious, however, there are people who genuinely believe that a strike from a katana is enough to cleave straight through the metal of the helmet. This is not the case! For sure, if you swing the damn thing hard enough then physics will eventually win. pressure is equal to force divided by area, so by making the impact surface as fine as possible and the force as great as possible, you may eventually be able to cut into the helmet. The force required to do this, however, is immense, and would be almost impossible to bring to bear against a moving and fighting target! What is more, even if a cut from the blade managed to make an incision in the helmet, that is no guarantee of inflicting any sharp force trauma or lacerations to your opponent. Now that is not to say that the blunt force trauma would not be significant, it would! We’re just saying that it probably wasn’t the ideal way of using a sword. Now give a man a kanabo (literally one of my favorite samurai weapons ever!) and we’re singing a whole different tune.

IMG_1731

 

2. Do, or body, is generally a lateral strike across the torso.

do2

Image courtesy of empty mind films

 

Once again if we apply this strike to a fully armoured warrior, we can see that it would have little effect against the robust metal of the cuirass or do. Sure, you might do some damage, but it will likely only dent the metal and chip the paint which, far from killing him, will probably just make him angrier!

IMG_1735

 

3. Kote, or wrist, is aimed at the top of the hand or forearm.

kote1

Image courtesy of empty mind films

As you can see, however, Alex’s arms are well protected, from the plates around his upper arm to the metal spines on his forearm, chainmail around his elbow and plates covering the back of his hands. While we can’t see this as a valid cut, however, we still think of strikes to the top of the wrist as a valid technique, as again, the blunt force trauma inflicted can break the joint, or force an opponent to lose his grip on a weapon.

IMG_1817

 

4. Tsuki, is a thrust directly to the throat.

tsuki 1

Image courtesy of empty mind films

As you can see in the image below, however, Alex’s throat is well guarded against attack. It is important to not that some Samurai would not have worn this guard at all times, making the tsuki to the neck a valid target. There are also ways of circumventing this protection, though these are not used in competitive kendo, and we will cover these in our next article!

IMG_1684

 

In modern naginata competition, the shin, or sune is also considered a valid target.

sune1

Image courtesy of empty mind films

Once again, this is a well protected area of the Samurai’s body, with sune-ate, or shin guards worn to protect against precisely this kind of attack. Some shin guards use spines instead of a solid construction, however, both render cutting or slashing attacks redundant. IMG_1738

Now am I being entirely unfair to kendo and modern naginata? Of course I am, I’m dragging them out of the time and context in which they were created, arts for sport and personal development in the peace prevalent under the Tokugawa shogunate and concluding (unsurprisingly) that they don’t work as combative techniques in the context of armoured fighting in the 1500’s. This was a necessary development to eventually turn martial arts, ways of killing, into a sport that could be practiced in a fun and safe fashion. Furthermore, I am not giving enough credit to the sword schools from which kendo draws its kata, some of whose techniques are manifestly intended to be used against unarmored opponents as was the main purpose of the samurai sword (see For the love of the Japanese sword), in which context, strikes to the head, body, wrist and throat become not only valid, but preferable targets! Kendo is a fantastic art, and a great sport with many adherents worldwide. It does not pretend to be, in its competitive form, proper fighting with swords, and my point is simply that it should not, therefore, be used as a reference when discussing samurai combat, and fighting warriors in armour.

In our next article (coming soon, I promise!) we will come at this from the opposite angle and answer the question: “what is the best way to kill a samurai?”

Samurai-Do 2016

All stills above from empty mind films products are used with the consent of the owner. We would also like to extend our thanks once again to the Iron Mountain Armoury for our gorgeous suit of armour!

 

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Koryu Bujutsu, Martial arts and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to How to Kill a Samurai: Part 1. How NOT to kill a Samurai!

    • Ah yes, I had heard about the Haga dojo, John Braely’s got a really good spot on them in the kendo episode of Warriors of Budo, certainly adds a little bit of spice the training! Not getting anywhere with the sword for some reason? It’s fine! just rugby tackle your opponent! Great stuff!

      Like

  1. Anonymous says:

    You might want to reword your introduction and budo / WWII. It makes it sound like modern budo didn’t start until after WWII at a passing read.

    Like

    • Thanks for your feedback, If we’ve made it sound like that then its definitely a mistake, I will have a look and see what I can do about that! Thanks for taking the time to let us know, we really appreciate it! 🙂

      Like

  2. Pingback: How to Kill a Samurai Part 2… | Samurai-Do

  3. Anon says:

    Interesting article, however I think you are over-looking one important element about Kendo. Bogu, is not representative of yoroi. Sure the construction looks similar, but is designed for sparring. Similar to a western fencing mask and vest. Kote, doh, and men, are not meant to actually represent armor.

    Just look at the zen nippon kendo no kata, both uchidachi and shidachi do not wear any form of protection to demonstrate the waza. Furthermore you can look into the various ryu-ha kendo was based on like Hokushin Itto ryu, Jikishinkage ryu, Jigen ryu, and various others. The techniques are very similar, with similar targets. Some waza are even downright the same, kiriotoshi-men from Houkushin itto ryu for example.

    Like

    • Hi there, that is exactly the point of the article, Kendo bogu is not traditional armour and therefore the kind of swordsmanship found in the Nippon kendo kata are not representative of armoured combat (I am not saying that they have no combat application whatsoever!)

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s